comments (10)

  • People here might be interested to know that you can run Scheme (lisp) code directly in Ableton through my Scheme for Max project in Max for Live.

    S4M is an open source extension to Max that allows you to run the s7 Scheme interpreter in a Max object, similar to the JS object in Max. Advantages over JS are that in can run in the high priority scheduler thread, enabling accurate timing, it has direct access to the file system from Scheme code, and allows you to make Scheme s-expressions directly in Max messages. It is also a very nice way to control the Live API, as the live API works on lists of symbols.

    https://github.com/iainctduncan/scheme-for-max https://www.youtube.com/c/musicwithlisp

    I'm planning another major release in the next few months as part of my PhD work.

    iainctduncan

  • Still no built-in way to collaborate with other musicians, it seems. While I understand the technical difficulties, it's also very frustrating to work remotely with other musicians on an Ableton project. I don't need real-time Google Docs like editing, but it would be nice to have something better than "freeze the project, dump it in Dropbox, and don't touch anything until they've made their edits".

    Any Ableton Live users here that can chime in on how they solve that?

    marceldegraaf

  • I can’t praise the folks at Ableton enough. In my early days of learning to be a music producer, I downloaded the demo for Live and made a track I liked. But then something went wrong and it didn’t get saved. The demo had recently expired while I was working on it and Live happened to crash when I went to go save it or something. It was just a fluke, probably having to do with the demo. But I contacted support to see if there was any chance I could recover the project if I paid for a license, which would have been a stretch for me at the time even for the basic version.

    They tried really hard to help me recover my work even without a license but weren’t able to. They then apologized and proceeded to give me a full Suite license for free. I couldn’t believe it, I mean this is serious professional software and I had never even been a customer. That showed me that they really stand behind their product. I was able to start making a living off of it and eventually when I could afford it I bought another license even though I didn’t really need it that badly, mostly as a thank you.

    The team over there is great and so is the software.

    sholladay

  • It's interesting to see them adopt this whole Rent-to-own model [1]. It's not quite a subscription since you end up with a full license to a particular version, but it is kinda like a subscription in the sense that a new version will be out by the time you are done with your payments. And it seems like you can "extend" it to get the new version, so it's a subscription with extra steps.

    IMO that's a better model for consumers since you do get something at the end of it. And if you are a professional, you were probably already getting the latest and greatest every time anyways.

    [1] https://www.ableton.com/en/rent-to-own-ableton-live/

    cruano

  • Shameless plug, but one of the toughest parts of working with Ableton Live is managing all your projects and keeping track of what's what.. unless you use REKALL[1]. An application I worked on (actually me, not claude, but claude did review a few bits) in order to help me manage my 400+ live sets.

    [1] https://rekall.machinelies.eu

    iamsaitam

  • After switching from Windows to Linux years ago the only application I ever missed is Ableton.

    I remember loving its basic effects: the (pingpong) delay, the reverb, the Eq, the compressor. And how easy it was to consolidate a track ander build further on top of it, cut it up, make a new instrument using it.

    Great software

    I tried running it with Wine but the experience wasn't great. And if it even worked, the VST's would be a whole new problem. So I dropped the hobby of digital musical production in favour of other hobbies

    stcg

  • New to music production but really want to give it a try. Can somebody please recommend resources/courses for beginners and which Abelton edition to buy: lite, intro, standard, suite? Also I was wondering if it is worth to buy akai mpk mini (play) to start with?

    semtud

  • Not new to 13 but I love Ableton's clean UI. Similar to Blender, it's how all creative apps (and systems!) should do it.

    NSUserDefaults

  • Wish they would add Linux support. What is the best option for Linux?

    alfyboy

  • Would you guys want to try out some pre alpha software built for exactly the use case of working remotely with collaborators on an ableton project?

    The project is called kolab, it grew out of the practical issue of composing and producing music remotely. A few years ago when I lived in London I had a band project with a mate, but after I moved home to sweden we wanted to continue and the only way we get it work reliably was to use git lfs with some jiggerypokering where each of us had a similar studio setup. We have made over 200 ableton projects with the workflow so we have a sense of what works or not.

    During the last year we have developed a system that is essentially an MVP, but we would welcome some people to test it in anger. Obviously its early days but we have spent the bulk of time making sure we have transactional semantics.

    It works through reading an als (its a gzipped xml file), extract the referenced assets and storing their contents under hash-based identifiers on cloudflare buckets and we then use the cloudflare Artifacts for als versioning.

    We do have a workflow we use manually for branching and merging that we have on the roadmap to implement as a feature but we are not there yet.

    When it comes to the ethics about dealing with the data, we both believe that when we go live we would prefer end to end encryption, but need to think about recoverability. One thing is very clear. We rather close the whole project than to let data be used for example for model training.

    We plan to have a free tier, but the idea is a small monthly subscription depending on usage. Currently we only support mac, but we do have windows support planned. What we have tested is the latest Ableton 12 version, but as you may know Ableton refuses to open projects saved in a never version. As a response for that we have experimental support of pushing a project as an Ableton 10 version.

    I also want to mention that the software is in the stage of yeah it works, but needs much more testing before we could bump it to beta. So bear in mind there will be bugs.

    If you are interested, please email: info at kolibrinkpg.com

    EastLondonCoder